Showing posts with label ethnography. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethnography. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Music Ethnography: Dallas Opera

1. Introduction
My goal when picking a music culture for this assignment involved choosing a culture that I was completely unfamiliar with. Unlike some others in my class, I selected a music culture that I do not interact with regularly. As a result, I will review the aspects of music culture surrounding opera within the Dallas area by using my experience at an opera event and other research. I will also detail what I observe to be a change in the way opera has traditionally been viewed, which is causing change in the opera movie culture of Dallas.

2. Methodology
2.1 Online Research
The primary source for this essay is The Dallas Opera website. The Dallas Opera is a company in Dallas, Texas. Their website has interviews, news, schedules and more information that will allow me to better understand opera in the Dallas area.

2.2 Live event
On February 24, I attended an encore presentation of Simon Boccanegra performed at The Metropolitan Opera and originally broadcast live on February 6 at a local AMC Theater. This source will help frame opera all aspects of music culture within the context of modern day technology and let me comment on the cultural differences between a more traditional opera environment and the experience that I had at the AMC theater.

3. Aspects of Opera
3.1 Ideas About Opera

The Dallas Opera's says that opera is similar to a musical but instead of having the characters in the stage show occasionally bursting into song, the singing never stops (“What is Opera”). Operas are theatrical performance that includes a stage, an ensemble up to a full orchestra and a live audience. Operas incorporate aspects from music, dance and theater. Modern operas incorporate styles from cultures all over the globe. In order to save the cultural flavor, the Dallas Opera usually performs their operas in the original language (“Frequently Asked Questions”). Operas are able to continue due to sponsorship and their ticket sales. According to a survey referenced on the Florida Grand Opera Orchestra's website, The Dallas Opera had a budget of 10.12 million dollars. To put this in perspective, The Metropolitan Opera, which is by far the largest opera company in the United States, has a budget of 249.02 million dollars (“Opera Statistics from Top 15 Metro Areas”).

3.2 Activities Involving Opera
As I mentioned earlier, operas are commonly performed by a live audience in what is called an opera house. The Dallas Opera says that audience members to an opera usually wear business attire but even casual-wear is certainly allowed (“Frequently Asked Questions”).

After going to the movie theater broadcast of Simon Boccanegra performed at The Metropolitan Opera there are a lot of observations that I have made about the type of people who participate in this music culture. In total there was 13 people in the theater, all of which had white or gray hair except for 2 people, excluding me. None the audience looked under the age of 30 except for me, so from my observations, it seems like the music culture of opera consists of mid to late aged people. With no one in the audience that I could identify as anything other than Caucasian, there was little ethnic diversity in the audience. With what little I could see of the audience in The Metropolitan Opera House, I could draw the same conclusions about the ethnic diversity and age group and most audience members wore business attire. There are several aspects of watching a live event broadcast into a theater that made me consider the cultural shift that is happening because of the availability of technology.

  • The movie theater atmosphere made the event a less of a social event than going to an opera house would. In the two intermissions of the nearly four hour opera, there was little conversation.
  • Even though the event was broadcast all around the United States, there was very few people in each movie theater watching the show. This changes the way people can experience an opera drastically.
  • The nationwide broadcast allows for a larger audience since it will be more convenient to go to a local movie theater than it is to drive into the nearest major city.
  • The actual content is different. Instead of seeing a live event you are looking at a flat screen with a projected image with speakers playing the recorded audio. With this format, the pre-show content was able to have interviews and commercials which is uncommon in opera house showings.

3.3 Repertoires of Opera
The Dallas Opera lists the most popular operas as the following: “Aida (the Egyptian opera, elephants are optional), Boheme (or, to be precise, La bohème, a tale of starving artists that continues to inspire works like Rent and the movie musical Moulin Rouge), and Carmen, the opera that proves that smoking isn’t the only thing bad for your health” (“What is Opera”).

The Met Opera could be causing the same situation as the professional versus amateur performers in matsuri festivals in Japan. Just like the traveling professional performers subtract from the local flavor for each festival, the live events being broadcast to movie theaters could make opera fans less likely to attend a local opera in favor of the live broadcast of The Metropolitan Opera. The Dallas Opera does not do touring shows. They are produced to be performed in a small time frame and will be put into the warehouse so you might have once chance to see a particular production live (“What is Opera”).

3.4 Material Culture of Opera
Operas incorporate a lot of cultural elements of the original opera including the fashion and setting. Thus, a large amount of work is put into making realistic looking sets, costumes and makeup.

Conclusion
Opera contains a music culture that incorporates many other cultures in the performances and incorporates many aspects of those cultures into a completely sung theater performance with elaborate costumes, set designs, makeup and orchestral music. Operas have a vast history over several centuries but still continues to hold a relatively large audience and will probably continue to entertain many in one form or another. Despite popular consensus, operas have greatly changed and has adapted to using technology to provide closed captions for English-speaking audience and provide digital access at home or in a theater.

Works Cited
“Frequently Asked Questions.” The Dallas Opera. 2010. The Dallas Opera. 9 Mar. 2010 <http://www.dallasopera.org/learn/faq.php>.

“Opera Statistics from Top 15 Metro Areas.” Florida Grand Opera Orchestra. 9 Mar. 2010 <http://fgomusicians.org/item/opera-statistics-from-top-15-metro-areas>.

Simon Boccanegra . By Giuseppe Verdi. Dir. James Levine. Perf. Plácido Domingo. The Metropolitan Opera, New York. 24 Feb. 2010. Performance.

“What is Opera.” The Dallas Opera. 2010. The Dallas Opera. 9 Mar. 2010 <http://www.dallasopera.org/learn/what_is_opera.php>.

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Blog Post 8: Ethnography Status Update

My research for the ethnography is going well. Dallasopera.org will probably be one of my main sources because it has a lot of information on the history of the company, press releases, interviews and learning material. The interview aspect of my project has proven to be very difficult. Since I changed my ethnography topic relatively late, I haven't gotten email correspondence from a performer at The Dallas Opera. I might not be able to include that part in my final ethnography report. Instead, I will draw from interviews that The Dallas Opera have on their website. I wanted to find a source for statistics of Opera-goings like attendance levels over the years but it seems like there isn't a specific survey about that. If there is, please let me know!

Friday, March 5, 2010

Blog Post 7: Dallas Opera


I decided to change my topic for the music ethnography towards somewhere that had more live music so I can fulfill that requirement of the assignment. The music culture that I'm now studying is the Opera culture in the Dallas area. Opera is simply a drama play where the libretto, script of an opera, is mostly sung. There's usually instrumental aspects to operas ranging from a small ensemble to a full orchestra. Opera is usually performed in Opera houses which are theaters that have a stage, seating and an orchestra pit. Fans of opera usually go to live performances but lately the trend of streaming opera to theaters has grown.

The event I have been to was a live broadcast at my local AMC Theaters. I watched a NCM Fathom presentation of Verdi's Simon Boccanegra performed at the The Metropolitan Opera.

Since I am a technologist, I plan to focus on how the technology has drastically changed the music culture. I have a couple quick bullet-points for this aspect:
  • Less social event.
  • Smaller audience per movie theater.
  • Nationwide participation.
  • More convenient.
  • Able to have different types of content (Interviews, commercials, etc.) before the show.
  • Non-live experience. There's nothing like actually "being there."
Below is the Google trend graph for the keywords Dallas opera. I was looking to see if there's a downward or upward trend but it seems to be cyclical. I then queried the keyword opera to see if there was a trend with opera in general and it seems that it's mostly unchanging but the news results are steadily rising over the years.


Related Links:

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Blog Post 2: Ethnography Proposal

For my ethnography I was thinking of studying the local Thai scene. I'll do this by going to a Thai restaurant that I've been to before called Noodle Wave. This restaurant has a very distinct atmosphere that seemed to be very unique. The food, the music and the people all seemed to have an overall different feel than most restaurants. I believe there are currently two locations for this restaurant, so this restaurant is currently very localized.

http://www.noodlewave.com/